Stephani begged for an ambulance to come quickly, which may be why Potack was able to survive the attack. Denise manages to open the door but is stabbed several more times, her screams awake a man nearby, who confronts Stephani, causing him to flee. The story also delves into how he was able to infiltrate a family and use their weaknesses to his advantage. When Stephani was attacking his victims, I believe he was attacking his former girlfriend because he felt so betrayed by what she did to him.. They could have been [made with] a Phillips screwdriver or an ice pick, said Det. Pathology Afterwards, Stephani would take them to a secluded location and kill them by a variety of ways during random attacks, mostly stabbing. Profiler KimberlieMassnicktheorized that during the calls, the killer was going into a juvenile state. Eating food was part of life. The calls made bythe Weepy-Voiced Killer, whose real name was Paul Michael Stephani,were different. [8], During Stephani's trial in the Simons murder case, Stephani's ex-wife, sister and a woman who lived with him testified that they believed the hysterical caller revealing the attacks was Stephani. Authorities attempted to trace the call, but it was too short. Evil Genius tells the story of the pizza bomber heist and the murder of Brian Wells in 2003. He died in prison in 1998 from skin cancer.[8]. Stephani, however, remembered no identifying information about the woman, only that he had drowned her in a bathtub. As police were attempting to track this man down, he attacked his final victim. Always admitting his crimes in a high pitched, sniveling voice, Stephani gave details of murders only he would know; however, he seemed to hang up whenever the emergency dispatcher attempted to get information about Stephani himself. Investigators were given the tape after a family whose car had broken down found it wrapped in an old military fatigue jacket beside Highway 205 near Stockton, Calif. in August 1989. The Weepy-Voiced Killer If I was ever in prison doing life I would have gladly beat this weirdos brains in. Be sure to click the video to hear the Weepy Voiced Killer himself and his phone calls to police! Stephani suffered a serious head injury when Denise Williams hit him over the head with a glass bottle. Much like a child being caught red-handed, he promised, Ill try not to kill anybody else.. The man saw a woman being stabbed with a screwdriver and was threatened when he attempted to intercede. Season 2 of Mark of a Killer kicks off on April 9 on Oxygen, and the first episode will feature the chilling case of a killer in the early 1980s in Minnesota, who became known as The Weepy-Voice Killer. The man attempted to intervene, but the suspect threatened him and then fled the scene in his car. Sergeant Joe Corcoran, who was interviewed for the episode, said he saw extreme rage in this one., With Potack, she had been so severely beaten that her brain had become exposed. The 19-year-old realized something was wrong when the killer drove through a dark, secluded area rather than heading back toward downtown Minneapolis. Paul Michael Stephani, a.k.a. True Crime : Barbara Simons (Murdered 1982) @Crimedoor Simons let Stephanigive her a ride home in his car. He recorded all of it on video. He decided to confess to the murders of Kim Compton, Barbara Simons and Kathy Greening. The first person police wanted to speak to in relation to the murder was the man that Simons had met at the bar, the man who had supposedly given her a lift home. However, there was a lot of blood and lacerations to the head that caused investigators to look into a possible homicide. Her name was Karen Potack, a 20-year-old American Indian woman. A year later, on July 21, 1982, Kathleen Greening was found drowned in her bathtub. The same if you are carrying your wallet in your back pocket. Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb, Horror Movies That Don't Look Like Horror Movies, The Real Killers Who Inspired Buffalo Bill, The Weepy-Voiced Killer Mercilessly Attacked His Victims - And His Tearful 911 Calls Are Chilling, The first person that Stephaniattacked was Karen Potack. Paul Michael Stephani | Criminal Minds Wiki | Fandom Also Read: 'Making a Murderer' Lawyers to Host New True-Crime Podcast About Wrongful Convictions. She sustained some of the worst injuries seen by investigators, but she lived. Only a few hours later did Stephani call investigators again, telling them to just listen as he explained his regret about killing Compton. The second attack occurred on June 3, 1981, and resulted in the death of . [1]His fourth victim (and the last victim who he killed) was Barbara Simons, a 40-year-old nurse on theMinneapolisside of the river. On the afternoon of June 3, 1981, a group of teenagers were playing in a field near a freeway construction site in St. Paul when they discovered the body of a young woman. Despite monitoring, Stephani went to the city's red light district, solicited a prostitute named Denise Williams and had sex with her in his apartment. There, first responders found 20-year-old college student KarenPotack, who had been beaten and stripped nude in a snowbank. "Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes" (Netflix). Minnesota Serial Killers: Part 1 - Paul Michael Stephani Sure enough, there was an unsolved case of a woman who was drowned in a bathtub. Luckily, Karen Potack survived. Stephani himself called police at 3 a.m. to report the attack, directing police to a location where "There is a girl hurt there." 1981 Kimberly Compton was the first one over in St. Paul.. Williams found a glass bottle in the carandsmashed it across his face, allowing her to escape before the witness called for help. He killed her inWisconsin on June 3, 1981, stabbing her61 timeswith an ice pick and strangling her with a shoelace. Maybe he knew something about her murder; maybe he was the murderer. About a decade after he was sentenced to 40 years in prison, Stephani reached out to Corcoran, saying if he does him one favor, hell tell him everything. The ordeal ended with rape, arson and a triple homicide. From Wikipedia: On December 31, 1980, Stephani beat Karen Potack inPrescott, Wisconsin, inflicting severe wounds and brain injury. Episode 200: The Weepy Voiced Killer - Listen - Morbid Cassie was murdered by two of her friends when she was alone, house sitting for family. Sometimes when creepythings happen, theres evidence left behind. He didn'tattempt to contact the police or local newspapers about thekilling, making itan outlier. When he called the St. Paul Fire Department asking for assistance, the department noticed the caller has aural similarities to the so-called Weepy-Voiced Killer phone calls. Stephani called authorities saying he needed help after he was hit in the head during a robbery gone wrong. During the attack, Williams was able to hit Stephani on the head with a glass bottle, causing cuts to his head and face. The man down the line declared: God damn, will you find me? Without her asking to, he pulled over and began stabbing her with a screwdriver before she smashed a glass bottle across his face and escaped. Occupation After killing her, he again contacted police pleading: God damn, will you find me? A devout Catholic,Paul MichaelStephani confessed to three slayings and two attempted murders after he was diagnosed with terminal cancer. I stabbed her 40 times. In 1980 on New Year's Eve Paul Michael Stephani brutally attacked Karen Potack after abducting her from outside of a bar. The little girl, who was 7-years-old, was taken to a local hospital where an examination revealed that she. I always found this one creepy. His first call came at 3 a.m. on December 31, 1980, after the attempted murder of Karen Potack. As the nightclub was closing at 1AM, her friends noticed that Potack was nowhere to be found; she had already left and was walking the short distance back home. He even mentioned that he killed one more woman no one ever pinned on him. Stephani killed three women in the MinneapolisSaint Paul area. He confessed his crimes to police and news stations, tearfully pleading that they make him stop. Paul Michael Stephani. This case was also covered in an episode ("Rough Winds & High Waters") on the podcast My Favorite Murder on May 23, 2019. Investigators found no clues at the crime scene, but 48 hours later, they received a tip in the form of an anonymous phone call to the station. I stabbed her 40 times. Two days later, police received a disturbing phone callthat connected Simons deathto the two otherattacks. However, when police got there, he had already vanished. Instead, they set up surveillance at his apartment and followed him when he left for Minneapolis; however, the lost track of him. Stephani wasnt able to give any true reason why he killed. He was found guilty of the murder of Barbara Simons but due to lack of evidence, he couldnt be tied to the other murders. To me, it seemed like killing was part of life, until I did it. In 1993, Karen MacKenzie and her three children - ages 16, 7 and 5 - were brutally murdered in their remote home in Greenough, Western Australia. On December 31, 1980, he beat Karen Potack to death while she was on her way home from a New Year's Party in Prescott, Wisconsin, and she was found naked in the snow, unconscious. On December 31, 1980, Stephani beat Karen Potack in Saint Paul, Minnesota, inflicting severe wounds and brain injury. This event resulted in police dubbing the caller, "The Weepy-Voiced Killer". Virtually non-existent. Thats truly very scary. That was part of his profile, that if I come forward and say I did this and I want to confess to this that I will be absolved from this event, FBI Special Agent Larry Brubaker told Mark of a Killer.. Simons was found floating in the Mississippi River with circular stab wounds littering her body. This upset Stephani very much, said Det. Sick freak I hope he got gang r4ped repeatedly in prison. Stephani later confessed to drowning her in her bathtub at her Roseville, MN residence. On 26 September, 2008, the police of Lusby, Maryland, received multiple phone-calls from worried citizens that reported seeing a young girl running down the street. I got beat up and Im bleeding, the man said. This Netflix true-crime doc looks into Henry Lee Lucas, known as one of America's most prolific serial killers, who admitted to hundreds of murders. The skeletal remains of two young boys were discovered in Stanley Park, Vancouver, Canada, in 1953. At the location, officers find Potack's naked body in a snow bank near railroad tracks, she had beaten to the point in which her skull had cracked, despite her severe injuries, Potack survived the incident, but is still recovering from brain trauma. Someone who is wanted by police would never call authorities for help, right? Every killer has a mark a signature move after their crime has been committed. Her killer has never been identified and the motivation for the murder remains unknown. Despite the fact that the killer had by now left multiple phone calls, police still hadnt identified him. THE SIREN Copyright 2023 FLEX WordPress Theme by SNO Log in, Your email address will not be published. When reporters spoke to Stephani after his conviction, he told them that he would hear voices telling him to kill. She sustained multiple wounds to the head and neck area, leaving her brain exposed. Kimberly Compton was the first one over in Saint Paul I killed more people Ill never make it to heaven! he cried. Its really fucked up but theres something so bizarre and disturbing about Grave Robbing for Morons. But when he was brought into the station and confronted with the crimes, his voice changed during his defense, and investigators knew they had their guy. I can't stop myself. Morbid - Episode 200: The Weepy Voiced Killer on Stitcher Stephani offered Denise to drive her back to the district and she accepted it. In June of 1981, another woman was found in St. Paul near a freeway construction site by a group of teenagers. See below for the 6 most disturbing details of the episode. In a whimpering, barely coherent voice he cried: Im sorry for what I did to Compton. His next victim was Kathleen Greening, also inSt. Paul. YOU'VE REACHED YOUR MONTHLY ARTICLE LIMIT. Stephani was born on September 8, 1944 and raised in Austin, Minnesota; as one of ten children by a highly religious family. On the 3rd of June, 1981, a group of teenage boys stumbled across a gruesome scene. She sustained some of the worst injuries seen by investigators, but she lived. Five months earlier, on New Years Day 1981 at 3 a.m., someone called begging for assistance with the same weepy voice. ", His next victim was Kimberly Compton, an 18-year-old student from Pepin, Wisconsin on June 3, 1981 in neighboring Minneapolis. 20-year-old Karen Potack, a University of Stevens Point student, was attending a nightclub with several friends. Stephani died of cancer on June 12, 1988. Using investigative research combined with primary audio, Morbidology takes an in-depth look at true crime cases from all across the world. Fourteen months later, police find the body of Barbara Simmons on a Minneapolis river, she had been stabbed to death. The details of his hanging dont really point to suicide.). Also Read: 'Trials of Gabriel Fernandez': 9 Most Shocking Details About the Murder at Heart of Netflix Documentary. She sustained some of the worst injuries seen by investigators, but she lived. The woman was identified as 18-year-old Kimberly Compton, a recent high school graduate who had moved from Wisconsin in search of a job that same day. Two days after the discovery of Comptons body, the man called 911 once again. He confessed all this after learning he had cancer, and all he was able to say about his urge to kill was a voice in his head that said, Paul, its time to kill!. He told officers he hadnt meant to kill the girl and that he would turn himself in. Following Kimberly's murder, police once again received an emotional phone call from her attacker. One difference in this case was that Stephani never called in about this crime, like in his other crimes. She was dead by the next morning. One killer led the police to where they buried all the evidence, never mentioning the tape. In one of his later phone calls, he said, "I'll never make it to heaven." 2. Further in-depth investigative work later connected Stephani to the murder of Simons. I stabbed her 40 times. I keep killing somebody. Police were successful in tracing the phone call to a pay phone at a bar across the street from the bus depot at 9th and St. Peter Street. When police and paramedics arrived on the scene, they were horrified by the brutality of the attacker.