The review question acts as a foundation for an integrative study (Riva et al. National Journal of Community Medicine. As with most things, if it seems too good to be true, it probably is. Kendall G. Bealls legacy in the battle against predatory publishers. your express consent. In Phase Two, the team . This clearly highlights the need for improvement to firewall/sequestration practices. Some nurse authors might submit their manuscript to a predatory journal without realizing it until after the submission or publication of the article. Thankfully, a second invited author contacted me directly to discuss our collaborative, interdisciplinary article. Articles consistent with the title and aims of the journal, for example. Weve spent a bit of time for surfin prominent authors in online. The publishers of predatory journals engage in unethical publishing practices, thereby endangering the scientific basis of the profession. What immediate impression does it convey? Our data also suggest that of the 10 million emails that penetrate these firewalls, potentially one-third are phishing emails. 7 Imagine the implications of making clinical practice recommendations that are based on low-quality or inaccurate data. Most predatory journals share characteristics that can help nurses identify and avoid them. In Google or Google Scholar, if an unfamiliar name of a journal turns up, then conduct due diligence to learn more: Although predatory journals have been in existence for less than 2 decades, they have already caused damage to the scientific literature. Whether writing, citing, or reading journal articles, they must develop a keen awareness to avoid falling prey to predatory publishing, understand the key concepts underpinning the problem, know the indicators that can help evaluate whether a resource may be predatory, and use reputable tools to aid in determining a journals legitimacy. A cross-sectional comparison, Predatory journals: the rise of worthless biomedical science, Consensus statement on the adoption of the COPE guidelines, The downside of the shifting paradigm of scholarly publishing in the biomedical sciences: predatory publishing, ac.secivreshtlaehatrebla@nosrekcin.nacnud, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/, https://libguides.caltech.edu/c.php?g=512665&p=3503029, https://www.spydermail.com/spam-cost-calculator/, World Journal of Surgery and Surgical Research, International Journal of Critical Care and Trauma, Sent from free provider (e.g., gmail.com), Claim to offer editorial services and/or a peer review process, Broad range of documents accepted (e.g., research, review, case report, editorial, clinical image, letter to editor), Publisher/standalone journal online presence, Organization is verifiable online (i.e., listed on PubMed, Disclaimer present at the end of the email, Use of appealing words to make the journal appear international (e.g., global, world, euro), Previous publications by the recipient are cited in the invitation, Invitation is related to surgeons specialty, Email sent from a free provider like gmail.com, Use of appealing words to make the conference appear international (e.g., global, world, euro). Checklists to detect potential predatory biomedical journals: a Integrative Medicine Reports | Mary Ann Liebert, Inc., publishers Keyword Highlighting Journal of Integrative Nursing - DOAJ Nurses should not use Google and Google Scholar only for a search because predatory publications can be found via these search engines, and there is no assurance of the accuracy of the information. Identifying these publishers and their journals can be tricky, but several trustworthy organizations can aid in decision-making long before you submit anything for publication. and D.N.). The aim of the journal is to contribute to the growing field of nursing practice and provide a platform for researchers, physicians and . Palliative Care in Heart Failure: An Integrative Review of Nurse One author reported falling prey to a predatory journal and encouraged other authors to check both the journal name and publisher on Bealls list before submitting an article.9. October 4, 2017. Check. . Analysis of the Theory of Integrative Nurse Coaching Websites for, Is the journal name misleading or confusing? ARC Journals. Submit., which works to address issues with open access, defines predatory publishers as those which charge authors a fee for publication with no intention of providing the expected servicessuch as editorial or peer reviewin return. Berger and Cirasella describe predatory OA journals as journals that exist for the sole purpose of profit, not the dissemination of high-quality research findings and furtherance of knowledge. More recently, Grudniewicz and colleagues developed this definition: Predatory journals and publishers are entities that prioritize self-interest at the expense of scholarship and are characterized by false or misleading information, deviation from best editorial and publication practices, a lack of transparency, and/or the use of aggressive and indiscriminate solicitation practices.. Adherence to recommendations of organizations such as the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) for conducting, reporting, editing, and. I encourage authors to delete unsolicited emails from predatory journals and continue to submit manuscripts to journals that are recognizable and a good fi for your area of expertise (clinical or research) and target audience. Predatory articles may be found in a search using Google or Google Scholar.6,15,16 Google allows you to quickly search the World Wide Web and internet for information about almost any topic. At more than 3 Even experienced authors are challenged by the volume and questionable legitimacy of emails from predatory journals. Apex Journal. From the Department of Surgery, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alta. Heather Carter-Templeton is the chairperson of the Adult Health Department and an associate professor at West Virginia University. Journal due diligence is a helpful strategy that authors can use to select an appropriate journal for their manuscripts.20 When searching for information or as a reader, use the same steps to evaluate the quality of a journal found during a search. With respect to the integrative review method, strategies to enhance data collection and . HHS Vulnerability Disclosure, Help Emails often contain writing, grammar, style, and spelling errors (for example, an email opens with, Good times for you!). 2016. Traditional and Integrative Medicine The journal focuses on rigorous quantitative and qualitative research including systematic reviews, clinical trials and surveys, whilst also welcoming medical hypotheses and clinically . Applied Science Innovations ( note: their journal "Carbon: Science and Technology" is indexed by DOAJ) APST Publication. 10. 20. In 2012, that list became known as Bealls List and was posted on his scholarly publishing blog. N1 - Funding Information: This work was made possible in part by funding from The Patrick and Catherine Weldon Donaghue Medical Research Foundation and Award number R21NR011334 from the National Institute of Nursing Research. Predatory publishers have minimal editorial board oversight, have limited, if any, peer-review of accepted articles, and promise a quick turn-around from the time the article is received until a decision is made to accept and publish the article. ; High Visibility: indexed within Scopus, ESCI (Web of Science), PMC, PubMed, and other databases. Jeffrey Beall, a librarian at the University of Colorado, first coined the term predatory in relation to publishing or journals. . In the event that these journals do actually publish, the lack of adequate peer review dilutes the quality of evidence within the literature.4. (New) List of Predatory Journals - 2023 Open access journals doi: https://doi.org/10.4037/ccn2019529. Consider this type of solicitation a red flag. The authors work at The Ohio State University Health Sciences Library in Columbus. Scan some recently published articles in the journal. Coll Res Libr News. Leslie H. Nicoll is the editor-in-chief of CIN: Computers, Informatics Nursing and Nurse Author & Editor and the president and owner of Maine Desk LLC. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the How to identify predatory journals in a search - LWW Baas J, Schotten M, Plume A, Ct G, Karimi R. Scopus as a curated, high-quality bibliometric data source for academic. ISSN 2768-749X (Online) | Integrative Journal of Nursing and Medicine. . Authors who may be at risk for publishing in a predatory journal are those who have had an article rejected following peer-review and are looking for a less rigorous process to achieve a successful publication.6 Citing potentially low-quality articles may reduce the quality of your own article as well as undermine the body of science in your area of expertise.7 Oermann et al7 located 814 citations to articles published in predatory nursing journals between 2009 and 2018. Follows recommendations and may state this on the journal website. government site. 3. Putting a stop to this practice will involve authors, reviewers, educators, researchers, editors, and clinicians. This text identifies both the skills and theoretical frameworks for . Annette M. Bourgault; Predatory Journals: A Potential Threat to Nursing Practice and Science. nternational Journal of Research in Engineering and Science (IJREAS) NanoWorld Journal (NWJ) National Journal of Basic Medical Sciences. 19. The overall cost to health care organizations in terms of wasted bandwidth and financial diversion is extensive, as is confusion for trainees and colleagues. Nearly all publishers and stand-alone journals (91.9%), as well as the majority of conference hosts (71.2%) identified as potentially predatory in nature were associated with a website; therefore, online verification is not a reliable way of determining the legitimacy of a phishing email. Briefly, they used Beall's original . Automated web crawlers locate authors email addresses by trolling a variety of websites to obtain author information. Quality databases have criteria that journals must meet before being accepted. In 2017, Beall took it down abruptly. . Case No. Shamseer L, Moher D, Maduekwe O, et al. With legitimate journals, authors have an option to withdraw a manuscript prior to its publication. Educators can help to disseminate this information and reviewers and editors can help by screening for predatory journals when they review publications. It is important to note, however, that 58% of emails (n = 119) did not contain any clues that they were sent from predatory journals,5 making it difficul to distinguish emails from legitimate journals from those that are from predatory journals. This is an important distinction to make as the scientific community moves toward a more open science model in response to scientific cultural shifts and funder mandates. Additionally, emails often include grammatical errors, peculiar word choices, exaggerated compliments about your extraordinary work, and lack professional language,5 including the following: Hope this email find you in good spirits! Almost all of the predatory email invitations originated from either fake journals (55.1%) or conference hosts (43.9%). Marilyn H. Oermann is the Thelma M. Ingles professor of nursing at Duke University School of Nursing and the editor-in-chief of Nurse Educator and Journal of Nursing Care Quality. This article shares guidance to help nurses effectively appraise information and their sources, distinguish predatory from legitimate journals, and conduct due diligence. J Nurs Scholarsh. 8 collected data on the characteristics of predatory nursing journals and surveyed authors, reviewers and editors about their experiences. They may accept articles for publication without conducting a thorough peer review of the research methodology and content.1-4 Importantly, articles in predatory journals may contain errors and misleading information, have significantly flawed research methods, and even include plagiarized content.1-7 In a study of nursing predatory journals, only half of the articles (n = 177, 50.9%) were related to nursing (for example, some of the articles in nursing journals were on dentistry), and one-third (n = 114, 32.4%) had errors in the research methods or did not report a review for the protection of human subjects. See: Journal of Case Reports in MedicineTrends in Transplantatio, Journal of Clinical and Molecular Medicine, Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases, Biology, Engineering and Medicine Journal, Journal of Clinical Investigation and Studies, Biomedical Research and Clinical Practice, United Journal of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Journal of Pharmaceutical Regulatory Affairs: Open Access, International Journal of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Journal of Clinical and Experimental Transplantation, Journal of Clinical Microbiology and Antimicrobials, Journal of Phylogenetics and Evolutionary Biology, Journal of Surgical Techniques and Procedures, Family Medicine: Clinical Investigations and Experimental Medicine, Annals of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Journal of Dermatology and Plastic Surgery, Austin Journal of Clinical Trials: Open Access, Archives on Veterinary Science and technology, Archives of Surgery and Clinical Case Reports, Journal of Drug design, Delivery and Safety, Applied Clinical Pharmacology and Toxicology, International Journal of Critical Care and Resuscitation, International Journal of Oral and Craniofacial Science, International Journal of Veterinary Science and Research, Journal of Medicinal Chemistry and Research, Internation Journal of Dermatology and Clinical Research, Journal of Novel Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation, International Journal of Immunotherapy and Cancer Research, Journal of Clinical Pharmacology and Clinical Pharmacokinetics, International Journal of Pediatric Research, International Archives of Substance Abuse and Rehabilitation, International Journal of Cognition and Behaviour, Case Reports in Surgery and Invasive Procedures, Journal of Plant Biotechnology and Microbiology, Timely Topics in Clinical and Vaccine Research, Biology and Medicine Case ReportsClinical Trials and Vaccine Research, Journal of Pediatric Research and Child Health, Journal of Surgical Oncology and Clinical Research, Journal of Clinical Case reports and reviews, GSL International Journal of Surgery Open, GSL Journal of Clinical Research and Case Reports Access, GSL Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews, Pediatric Infectious Diseases: Open Access, Journal of Neurodegenerative Diseases and Disorders, Journal of Zoonotic Diseases and Public Health, Journal of Clinical Medicine and Therapeutics, Journal of Clinical and Molecular Endocrinology, Journal of Addiction and Clinical Research, Clinical Dermatology: Research and Therapy, Journal of Plastic Surgery and Cosmetology, Journal of Clinical Nutrition and Metabolism, Journal of Dermatology and Cosmetic Surgery, Advancements in Bioequivalence & Bioavailability, Examines in Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation, Orthoplastic Surgery & Orthopedic Care International Journal, Journal of Otolaryngology, Head & Neck Surgery, Journal of Brain and Neuroscience Research, Journal of Clinical Dermatology and Therapy, Journal of Psychology & Clinical Psychiatry, Journal of International Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation, international Journal of Open Access Ophthalmology, International Journal of Open Access Clinical Trials, Chronicle Journal of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews, Journal of Advanced Pediatrics and Child Health, Journal of Reconstructive Surgery and Anaplastology, Journal of Clinical and Experimental Pharmacology, Integrative Journal of Veterinary Biosciences, Journal of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Studies, Journal of Orthopaedics Spine and Sports Medicine, International Journal of Veterinary and Animal Medicine, Modern Applications of Bioequivalence & Bioavailability, Journal of Pediatrics and Palliative Care, Case Reports and Literature Review Journal, Journal of Veterinary and Animal Reseacrh, Annals of Clinical and Medical Case Reports, Potential predatory and legitimate biomedical journals: can you tell the difference? The fee is often not transparent, and journal websites may include misleading information about the costs. Oermann MH, Wrigley J, Nicoll LH, Ledbetter LS, Carter-Templeton H, Edie AH. If you are a practicing clinician who has not yet authored a paper, you may also be affected by articles published in predatory journals and not be aware of it. While power dynamics can influence interprofessional communication and care coordination, the field's understanding of these power structures during the COVID-19 pandemic is limited. Nursing2022 is a hybrid journal: It publishes articles without a fee, but authors can choose to pay to publish their articlewhich was done for this article. Insight Medical Publishing, popularly known as iMedPub LTD is an online, open access publisher that aims at advancing learning by circulating the scientifically researched information in the fields of Science, Technology and Healthcare. the contents by NLM or the National Institutes of Health. However, this is a subscription-based resource, so check with your library to see if you have access. URL: researchopenwor https://researchopenworld.com/category/integrative-journal-of-nursing-and-medicine/, Google: www.google.com/ https://www.google.com/search?q=ISSN+%222768-749X%22, Bing: www.bing.com/se https://www.bing.com/search?q=ISSN+%222768-749X%22, Yahoo: search.yahoo.co https://search.yahoo.com/search?p=ISSN%20%222768-749X%22. Search for Similar Articles You may be trying to access this site from a secured browser on the server. First, it is important to recognize that these emails are automated, similar to robocalls and texts. The journal name is often similar to a legitimate journal. Journal/Author Name Estimator (JANE) is another site that potential authors can use to decide on the best fi for their article.10 JANE flag journals that are indexed in Medline or considered to be high-quality open access journals. A literature search may yield a variety of types of articles. Pirinea, H., Simunich, T., Wehner, D., & Ashurst, GALLOP. The Journal of Evidence-Based Integrative Medicine (JEBIM) is a peer-reviewed open access journal which focuses on hypothesis-driven and evidence-based research in all fields of integrative medicine.Previously the Journal of Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine (JEBCAM). Most predatory journals appear to be more interested in profit than in the quality of scientific dissemination. Even with escalating emails and intervention by the legal department of the university or healthcare system, predatory journals may hold an article hostage and refuse to remove the article from the journal website. A further review of those 10 predatory journals revealed that 9 were originally published by a reputable publisher, and followed sound editorial and publishing practices at the time they were indexed, but were subsequently purchased by one of the large predatory publishers.15. Oermann et al7 located a total of 127 predatory nursing journals using Bealls list. For example, the National Library of Medicine has a Literature Selection Technical Review Committee that examines journal editorial policies, scientific rigor, and publishing frequency/consistency to determine if they merit inclusion in MEDLINE. Nursing Reports | An Open Access Journal from MDPI Find everything you need to get the most out of Liebert journals in your library and to keep your collection up-to-date. Complementary and alternative medicine services in the United . 2019;576(7786):210-2. doi:10.1038/d41586-019-03759-y. As an example, this article is open access: The authors chose to pay the fee to publish it open access so it would be free for readers and this information could be disseminated widely. Journal of Integrative Nursing 2666-9854 (Print) / 2663-4481 (Online) Website ISSN Portal About . In addition to journals offering voluntary OA options, since 2008, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) has required that scientists who receive NIH funding make their accepted publications freely available via PubMed Central, a publicly accessible digital archive of biomedical and life sciences journal literature. The widely used academic database Scopus hosts papers from more than 300 potentially 'predatory' journals that have questionable publishing practices, an analysis has found 1. 2019. Abstract Purpose: Personalized nursing is becoming the order of the day, hence nurses need to be prepared to engage with genetics and genomics in practice, in order to attend to individual patient needs. This article shares guidance to help nurses effectively appraise information and their sources, distinguish predatory from legitimate journals, and conduct due diligence. Affiliated with the International Society for Complementary Medicine Research. 1. Furthermore, our surgical trainees, research assistants and nursing collaborators are also finding it increasingly difficult to navigate the extensive web of deceitful possibilities and invitations. Although you might not reach a simple yes or no decision, you can weigh each indicator and come to a conclusion. A cross-sectional comparison. There are yet only a few studies on predatory publishing in nursing. Summary of phishing emails from predatory publishers seeking manuscript submissions, Summary of phishing emails from predatory stand-alone journals seeking manuscript submissions, Characteristics of phishing emails seeking manuscript submissions. If the website gives an impact factor (a number based on how frequently its published articles are cited), confirm the data in Clarivates Journal Citation Reports (the official source of Journal Impact Factors) or ask a librarian for assistance if you dont have access to this resource. Researchers also have studied the differences between predatory and traditional journals to improve the abil- Some legitimate journals also use a pay-to-publish model wherein authors pay a fee (referred to as an article processing charge) for their article to be open access. For more information, please refer to our Privacy Policy. Integrative Nursing | Oxford Academic With open access, the article is freely available for readers to download. A variety of lists have been created to help identify legitimate journals and reputable publishers. United States District Court, District of Nevada, Federal Trade Commission, Plaintiff, vs. OMICS Group Inc., et al., Defendants. Nurs Outlook. The sample included 21 studies that addressed the application, analysis, construction, validation or . - Blogger Based on our review, we suggest authenticating these emails by looking for characteristics indicative of a predatory email, including spelling and grammar errors, overly formal or stilted salutations, and a broad range of welcomed submission types (original articles, review articles, case reports, editorials, clinical images, letters to editors), and by consulting Bealls list to look for the publisher or journal name.